A new species description separates a large deep-sea shark from the Indian Ocean from its supposed relative in the Atlantic. Echinorhinus roinee, called Indian Bramble Shark in English, had been recorded as Echinorhinus brucus for decades. Only the joint evaluation of external characteristics and mitochondrial DNA showed that the animals form an independent line.
The specimens examined did not come from a targeted research trip. Deep-sea shrimp trawlers had landed them as bycatch – at the fishing port Sakthikulangara at Kollam in southwest of India. The new classification also shows how much unknown diversity can still be hidden in the ocean.
Under the wrong name for decades
Sharks of the genus Echinorhinus are large, bottom-dwelling sharks on continental slopes. Conspicuous, thorn-like skin teeth are typical. Because the Indian animals externally resemble Echinorhinus brucus, older catches and biological observations were attributed to this species. As a result, E. brucus appeared to be spread across several ocean basins.
The new species is not a discovery of a previously completely unseen animal. Rather, it is the result of a taxonomic correction: known material was reassessed using more precise measurements and genetic methods. This difference is crucial for inventory analyses. If two species are combined in catch statistics, their actual distribution areas and pressures remain invisible.
How researchers recognize Echinorhinus roinee
According to the Zoological Survey of India, Echinorhinus roinee reaches a length of up to three meters. The animals are dark brown to almost black. Large, thorn-like denticles sit on the skin, which in older specimens can grow together to form multi-pointed plates.
In direct comparison with related species, relatively larger eyes and pelvic fins are noticeable. The section from the snout to the gill slits is also longer. Such combinations of features provided the anatomical part of the diagnosis. The team also examined mitochondrial barcode sections. This DNA data separated the Indian lineage from both E. brucus from the Atlantic and E. cookei from the Pacific.
Possible spread beyond India
The confirmed specimens come from the Indian Ocean off Kerala and have been described in association with depths of around 350 to 450 meters. Genetically similar datasets from Oman, Sri Lanka and Thailand suggest the species may be more widespread. However, this is not yet a fully mapped distribution: museum holdings and new catches must be compared with reliably determined reference specimens.
The type specimens on which the species name is permanently anchored are in the National Zoological Collections of the Marine Biology Regional Center in Chennai. This allows later studies to compare their characteristics and DNA with the original material. The scientific description appeared in Volume 126, Special Issue 1, of the Records of the Zoological Survey of India. A reliably accessible article or DOI target page was not yet indexed at the time of going to press.
Bycatch provides data ā and puts the species under pressure
The fact that the crucial animals come from shrimp trawlers has two sides. Fishing ports give researchers access to deep-sea species that are rarely observed during expeditions. At the same time, the find shows that these animals are caught in bottom trawling nets. How often this happens cannot be determined from the species description alone. The population size, reproduction and mortality of E. roinee are not yet sufficiently known.
A new deep-sea catshark has already been described in the region before Kerala. Both cases make it clear that correct species names are not a mere formality. Without reliable determination, authorities can neither assign catch quantities nor recognize whether a rare species ends up as bycatch particularly often.
One species becomes two protection tasks
With the separation of Echinorhinus brucus, older information must be reread. A supposedly widespread population can split into several spatially separated species – each with its own population size and risk. This is exactly where the significance of the new description lies: For the first time, it creates the prerequisite for examining Echinorhinus roinee as a separate unit in fisheries data, red lists and protection plans.
It is still unclear how large its population is, where its nurseries are and which fisheries have the greatest influence. The new species therefore not only answers a taxonomic question. It makes visible which biological and political questions were previously hidden under the name of another species.

