Shark rescue on Réunion ends in legal dispute

A fisherman refuses a criminal warning after rescuing a juvenile shark from the bathing pool of Manapany. Now the public prosecutor’s office will decide on the further procedure.

Ronny K19. November 2026
View of the seawater pool of Manapany on La Réunion, protected by basalt rocks
Photo: Clémenceau Lauret, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons; cropped.

On November 16, 2026, the fisherman Bertrand Baillif refused a criminal warning with probation conditions. It had been offered to him after the rescue of a juvenile shark from the Manapany bathing pool in the south of La Réunion. Baillif admits to his involvement in the action but denies having committed a crime.

According to the reports in the media, the authorities accuse him of fishing in the sea without a permit as well as using a banned fishing gear. There is no conviction so far. Because Baillif did not accept the alternative measure, the decision on the further course of action now rests again with the public prosecutor’s office.

A juvenile shark in the bathing pool

The animal was discovered at the end of January in the Bassin de Manapany, a seawater pool protected by basalt rocks in the municipality of Saint-Joseph. The city closed access and swimming with a municipal decree of February 4, 2026. The confirmed presence of a young shark was cited as the reason.

According to a report by Didier Dérand at Imaz Press, the shark remained in the tank for twelve days. On February 11, three professional fishermen under the direction of Baillif, as well as divers and freedivers, brought the animal back to the open sea through an opening. Dérand describes an action lasting about 30 minutes, in which the shark was guided to the exit with a net and released outside the tank.

Which species was rescued is not reliably clarified. Later reports describe the approximately 60-centimeter-long animal as a young bull shark, while early assessments, due to its characteristics, also considered a grey reef shark possible. A confirmed professional or genetic identification is not documented in the accessible sources.

Rescue or illegal fishing?

At the center of the dispute is therefore not the release itself, but the legal classification of the method used. Baillif argues that it was a rescue operation and not fishing. According to media reports, the investigative authorities, on the other hand, see indications of violations of fishing regulations.

A rejected warning is neither an acquittal nor a conviction. The public prosecutor can discontinue the proceedings, propose another alternative, or initiate judicial prosecution. Until such a decision is made, the allegations remain unproven.

Shark protection remains controversial on La Réunion

The case touches on the debate that has been controversially conducted for years about how to deal with sharks around La Réunion, but differs from the programs aimed at the targeted removal of animals. Only in October did the organization VAGUES demand stricter limits for shark killings off Réunion. In Manapany, on the other hand, it is about rescuing a trapped young animal and the question of which means were legally permissible in doing so.

Sources

Newsletter

Shark alert in your inbox

Shark Alert in Your Inbox

Real News Instead of Myths!
- New Every Fortnight -